Minutes of Ennis Municipal District Meeting April 2024

Minutes of Ennis Municipal District Meeting April 2024

Present:

Councillors attending: 

Councillor P. Daly (Cathaoirleach)

Councillor J. Flynn (Leas-Cathaoirleach)

Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor M. Howard

Councillor C. Colleran-Molloy

Councillor T. O’Callaghan

Councillor A. Norton.

 

Officials attending in person:

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer

Paddy Tiernan, Acting Senior Executive Engineer

Niamh O’Connor, Administrative Officer and Meetings Administrator,

Lily McInerney, Staff Officer (minutes).

 

Apologies:

Carmel Kirby, Director of Service.

 

Presiding:

The Cathaoirleach, Pat Daly presided.  Cllr Daly opened the meeting welcoming all.

 

Votes of sympathy

The family of the late Timmy Murphy R.I.P. who had played for Ennis Albion before moving to Galway.

The family of the late Frank Custy R.I.P., a wonderful citizen who had taught music to so many.

Item 1: Minutes of March Meeting of Ennis Municipal District

 Amendments requested by Cllr. J. Flynn:

 

Item 3 (vi) S 38 at Newpark & Cappalawn Roslevan 

Replace “Roslevan mini roundabout” with “Roslevan shopping centre roundabout“.

 

Item 4, No. 1

Add the following text, prior to “It is recorded that Cllr J. Flynn withdrew ...” 

“Cllr J. Flynn stated he  has no actual conflict of interest with Clare Garden Festival as he had concern at a previous meeting he might have had and withdrew at that meeting.” 

 

 Subject to above amendments:-

Ar moladh Councillor A. Norton
Cuidithe ag Councillor M. Howard agus glacadh leis

“That the March 2024 Minutes of Ennis Municipal District be adopted.”

Item 2: Matters Arising

Cllr T. O’ Callaghan raised the issue of the recording of conflict of interest for GMA allocations once again, recommending the tabulated monthly GMA list include, in addition to the proposing Councillor, a column to name the Councillor who declared a conflict of interest for each item.  Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, clarified that conflict of interest is duly recorded in the minutes at each meeting where GMA is approved for allocation, Members are asked to declare such interest at the outset of the discussion.

Since the beginning of 2024, it was agreed to include the proposing Councillor on the list (which had not been done in recent times) and Sean advised that it may be somewhat excessive to add a further column when a process is already in place.  

Cllr Norton stated that during their term of office Councillors have always been diligent in the recording of any conflict of interest.  She explained also that Members as part of their role are involved with a wide range of organisations, often being asked to represent and speak on their behalf and whether the subsequent allocation of monies to these groups could be perceived as a conflict of interest. She reminded the meeting it was important to balance this representational role with the equal obligatory role of ensuring much needed funding reaches the organisations requesting it, and to this end, the recording of expenditure via receipts was an essential part of the validation process.

Cllr Howard cautioned that the essential point of GMA was being lost in this discussion, ie. to support small groups whose work benefits the community, most of whom work in a voluntary capacity and who rely on the funding to remain viable.  Also, contrary to current practice, her opinion was that the Councillor having declared the conflict of interest should remain in the room for the discussion as they are best positioned to answer questions other Members may have on that particular funding request. 

Cllr Flynn supported Cllr O’Callaghan’s request for a tabulated column for the recording of conflict of interest which he had understood was agreed at the January 2024 meeting.  Sean Lenihan clarified his understanding to be that an additional column would be added to include the Councillor proposing only and that conflict of interest is already recorded in minutes.

Cllr Murphy voiced concern that the discussion on conflict of interest served to cause confusion.  He outlined that three of his proposed groups for funding at this Meeting are small local groups whose work he wishes to support, whereas Clarecastle Regatta he would see differently as he has been involved with the group for the past 10 years and he questions now whether it is remiss of him not to step outside for this discussion? A further example is Killoo Church, as Cllr Murphy personally knows the people involved in the funding request and some of his own relatives are buried there, should he therefore declare and step out in this case.

Cllr O’Callaghan stated that when dealing with public money, and in the best interests of the public being served, everything needs to be documented in a proper manner and he would be concerned if any conflict of interest has not been recorded in the correct manner.

Sean Lenihan read out the definition of conflict of interest from the SIPO website.  It was agreed that this would be circulated to Members after the Meeting. Sean again reiterated that it was his view that what was in place was satisfactory but that he didn’t have difficulty in adding in the Conflict of Interest column in future.

Item 3: Ordinary Business 

(i)                 Declaration of Public Roads – Shanacloon, Cloonbeg, Clonlea and Moyard in the development Shanballa, Lahinch Road, Ennis, Co. Clare

Report and maps had been circulated in advance of the Meeting.

Ar moladh Councillor A. Norton
Cuidithe ag Councillor M. Howard agus glacadh leis

“that the Section 11 Declaration of Public Roads at Shanacloon, Cloonbeg, Clonlea and Moyard in the development of Shanballa, Ennis be adopted by Ennis Municipal District.”

Item 4: General Municipal Allocations for Approval

Members were reminded that if there was a conflict of interest in agreeing funding for proposed organisations, that they must declare this conflict and may wish to withdraw from the Meeting until after the discussion.

 

Conflict of Interest Declared:

It is recorded that Cllr Flynn declared a conflict of interest in two payments to benefit Clare County Agricultural Show and he withdrew from the Meeting during discussion on this item.

It is recorded that Cllr Howard declared a conflict of interest in a payment to benefit Ennis Community College, as she sits on the Board of Management.

It is recorded that Cllr Norton declared a conflict of interest in a payment to benefit Clare Crusaders.

Cllr O’Callaghan stated that whilst Clare Crusaders are to be commended for their hard work, it had been brought to his attention that Cllr Norton is a director of the organisation and therefore this represented a conflict of interest.  He added that GMA funds should be aimed at those organisations which have limited financial resources. He sought clarity that the proper regulatory rules are being followed.  Sean Lenihan clarified that Cllr Norton had declared the conflict and that it was duly noted for the record.

 

The two allocations to Clare County Agricultural Show, €1,000 and €3,000 respectively, were proposed by Cllr. P. Murphy, seconded by Cllr C. Colleran-Molloy and agreed by all Members.

 

All remaining items were proposed by Cllr C. Colleran-Molloy, seconded by Cllr. P Murphy and agreed by all Members.

Ar moladh Cllr. C. Colleran-Molloy
Cuidithe ag Cllr. P. Murphy  agus glacadh leis

“That the following GMA allocations be adopted:

              GMA Allocations for April 2024:

Councillor	Beneficiary	Amount	Conflict of Interest
Cllr Tom O'Callaghan	Holy Family School	€1,000.00
Cllr Tom O'Callaghan	Comhaltas - Fleadh Nua	€2,000.00
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy	Ennis Players	€1,000.00
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy	Comhaltas - Fleadh Down in Ennis	€2,000.00
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy	Clarecastle Tidy Towns	€300.00
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy	County Clare Agricultural Show	€1,000.00	Cllr J. Flynn declared
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy	Ailbhe O'Neill Athletic Bursary	€500.00
Cllr Mary Howard	Comhaltas - Fleadh Down in Ennis	€2,000.00
Cllr Johnny Flynn	Cappahard Residents Association - towards maintenance of the large green areas including grass cutting.	€2,500.00
Cllr Johnny Flynn	To fund a research/study project to document/catalogue reflections on the works and poetry of Brian Mooney.	€5,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis Scouts	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Spancilhill Fair	€2,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Comhaltas - Fleadh Nua	€2,500.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis Musical Society	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis Rugby Club	€2,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Clarecastle GAA	€2,500.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Clare Haven	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Eire Og Pitch Development etc	€10,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	RNLI	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Banner GAA	€2,500.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Clare Garden Festival	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Kilnamona Development Association	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Doora Barefield GAA	€2,500.00
Cllr Pat Daly	County Clare Agricultural Show	€3,000.00	Cllr. J. Flynn declared
Cllr Pat Daly	Holy Family School	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Toonagh Hall	€2,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis Men's Shed	€2,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis Town FC	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Avenue Utd	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Lifford FC	€1,000.00
Cllr Pat Daly	French Park Estate Residents Association	€500.00
Cllr Pat Daly	Clare Crusaders	€1,000.00	Cllr. A. Norton declared
Cllr Pat Daly	Ennis National School	€2,000.00
Cllr Ann Norton	Streetwise	€1,532.70
Cllr Ann Norton	Tour De Burren	€9,000.00
Cllr Ann Norton	Barefield Community Centre	€3,000.00
Cllr Ann Norton	Clare Crusaders Clinic	€10,000.00	Cllr. A. Norton declared
Cllr Ann Norton	Ennis Community College project with St Clare’s School	€5,000.00	Cllr. M. Howard declared
Cllr Ann Norton	Ennis West Mens Shed	€500.00
Cllr Ann Norton	Educate Together Sixth Class	€1,000.00
Cllr Ann Norton	Comhaltas Fleadh Nua	€2,000.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Clarecastle Quay Project	€5,000.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Clare GAA Water Drilling Project	€3,500.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Comhaltas, Fleadh Down in Ennis	€2,000.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Clarecastle Regatta	€2,000.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Killoo Church Restoration	€2,000.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Ennis Musical Society	€1,500.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Ennis Players	€1,500.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Kilnamona Defibrillator Project	€1,300.00
Cllr Paul Murphy	Kilnamona School Playground Project	€1,200.00
	Total	€113,832.70
Cllr Johnny Flynn & Cllr Mary Howard	Lifford Soccer Club - reallocation of funds Original application - provision of accessible and children’s toilets New request - replacement/provision of a safety spectator fence surrounding the pitch.   €3,000 from 2023	€3,000.00

 

Item 5: Notice of Motion No. 1 Ballybeg Traffic Calming Measures

Ar moladh Cllr. C. Colleran-Molloy
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan agus glacadh leis

 

No. 1     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. C. Colleran-Molloy

“Ballybeg

That traffic calming measures and signage be installed on the first road down from the Ballybeg Water tower due to the complaints of speeding in the neighbourhood”.

 

Paddy Tiernan, A/Senior Executive Engineer, responded as follows:

This road (L-8364) is a cul-de-sac which services approximately 20 residential properties. The current speed limit on this road is 50kmph. Ennis MD will carry out an assessment of this road in the coming weeks with a view to installing some traffic calming measures if deemed necessary. The most likely form of these measures would be increased signage and line marking. We note that no funding is currently available for this project.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

Cllr. Colleran-Molloy welcomed the response, thanking Paddy Tiernan for agreeing to undertake the assessment and hoping that the required funding can be identified.

This Motion was seconded by Cllr. O’Callaghan and supported also by Cllrs Daly and Murphy.  Cllr Murphy recommended that for this cul-de-sac it may be appropriate for residents to get together and purchase ‘children at play’ signage.  Paddy Tiernan confirmed that Ennis M.D.  would be happy to erect such signage, which he recommended as more useful and cost-effective than other remedies like road markings.  Sean Lenihan clarified that such signs would serve as a community warning only and would not have a statutory basis. 

Cllr Colleran-Molloy welcomed the support of Members and particularly the recommendation of Cllr Murphy, and the support of Ennis M.D.

 

 

Item 6: Notice of Motion No. 2  Clarecastle Taskforce

Ar moladh Cllr. T. O’Callaghan
Cuidithe ag Cllr. J. Flynn agus glacadh leis

 

No. 2     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan                                     

“To request Clare County Council, engage a Council led Clarecastle taskforce, incorporating the many progressive proposals within Clarecastle community groups.”

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

At the outset, I wish to acknowledge the great work being done presently and over many years by the various volunteer and community groups in Clarecastle for the benefit of the Village itself and its surrounding areas.  I understand that following a recent consultative process, initiated by Clarecastle Community Development CLG, a new Clarecastle Village Team has recently been established.  The purpose of the Consultation was to elicit people’s views relating to what they wanted in the community plan and to produce clear goals and objectives and to identify who best was needed to deliver on them. 

The Council, and in particular, Ennis MD staff along with our colleagues in Rural and Community Development and across the Organisation as required, would be delighted to assist the new Village Team and indeed any Community Group in the area, towards achieving their future goals and ambitions for Clarecastle and its surrounding areas. 

This item was seconded by Cllr J. Flynn and agreed by all Members.

Cllr O’Callaghan acknowledged the response and thanked Sean Lenihan for his acknowledgement of the great work already undertaken to invigorate this community which comprises of newcomers as well as long term residents whose shared vision is to make Clarecastle a great place to live, work and visit.  Whilst there have been commendable efforts via government grants and plans to drive these community wide priorities, he stated, there exists a gap between the wish list and funding and that the expertise of the Council was required for development of such a key hub in the district.

Cllr Flynn seconded this Motion.  Cllr Colleran-Molloy commended the Town Team approach as an effective means of attaining funding and she praised the commitment made to Clarecastle over the years, evident in public realm enhancements to the value of approx. €600k in recent times.

Cllr Murphy supported the ethos of the Motion but believed that the Motion should be worded to align with and assist the current process rather than seeking to create a new one.  The Town Team project is showing signs of success, has been supported via GMA, and there is momentum gathering for this in Clarecastle.

Cllr Daly supported the Motion and Clarecastle’s growth in recent times, clearly evidenced by developments like the Doora to Clareabbey greenway, the success of groups like the GAA, Comhaltas, Tidy Towns etc and that it will be positive for the Ennis M.D. to see Clarecastle flourish further.

Cllr Flynn added that he had not been happy that his proposal for two Town Teams in Ennis M.D. had not received the support of Ennis’s rural counterparts and he vouched for the benefits of the scheme experienced by Scarriff and Ennistymon.  He would have envisaged one for Ennis as a more appropriate mechanism than the establishment of Ennis 2040 DAC.

Cllr Howard acknowledged the huge investment for Clarecastle in recent times and she commended Cllr Murphy’s long standing endeavours to keep this item front and centre in Ennis M.D’s wish list.

Sean Lenihan stated that the Village Team is already set up and includes a range of community group representatives already He understood that there was an upcoming meeting on Wednesday April 10^th in the school hall.  Ennis MD have not been directly requested to lead on this but Sean confirmed that we were as always, happy to assist where possible and as required.  He mentioned the supports available from the Council’s Rural Development Section and in particular, Seamus Murrihy who is the RD Officer for the area.   Cllr O’Callaghan concluded, thanking Members and vouching that the aim is a unified wish to maximise the good of this community and to recognise the need for Council funding to get bigger projects through the line. 

 

Item 7: Notice of Motion No. 3  Public Car Parking

Ar moladh Cllr. J. Flynn
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan

 

No. 3     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. J. Flynn                                                  

“How do Ennis MD propose to address their reports on Public Carparking Deficit in Ennis.  

Further to recent reports & statutory replies from Ennis MD officials that in their opinion there is: 

 

1) a shortfall of 369 public car-parking spaces in Ennis from 2008 up to 2018 

2) that 159 public carparking spaces has been lost in Ennis to road works etc up to 2024

3) future losses due to active travel and Current public realm works 

 

I request a report on what the Ennis MD executive propose to address these significant deficits.

 * Note these figures do not address the Ennis Town Centre parking deficit resulting from the 1990s developments under two Urban renewal tax incentive schemes and pre 2008 Celtic Tiger building boom.” 

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

The Members will be aware from previous reports, replies, briefings, plans and proposals over the years of the changing demands and provision of carparking within the Town and its environs.   The optimum design of Traffic Management flows and Parking availability is an ever-evolving process with changes resulting from time to time as a result of initiatives and decisions taken.  These include introduction of one-way systems, public realm works, active travel proposals, coach parking, taxi parking, universal accessibility among others.  The most up-to-date information regarding what is available will emerge from the recent survey and report carried out by Punch Consulting Engineers and which is to be validated further by an additional Survey commissioned by Ennis MD and expected to be carried out in the coming months.  Once completed, this data driven report will supersede some of the historic reports which are now out of date and will be our guidance document for the future.

 

In response to what we are doing to counter these changes and to mitigate future demands, I wish to advise that Ennis MD are actively involved in a range of measures to maximise the benefit from the parking spaces available.  These include:

 

• Better management and regulation to optimise and use of existing parking.
• Proposals for improved signage, mapping, and real time information
• Promotion of modal shift to alternate transport modes
  • We continue to work on improved and new Local and Regional Bus Services for Ennis
  • Engagement with Schools and Businesses to reduce the amount of car journeys,
  • Active Travel proposals
• Provision of additional Town Centre adjacent parking subject to approval.
• Park and Stride Provision for long term parking requirements
• Future Provision of Park and Ride as Town Bus Service operation expands.

 

I will keep the Members updated of developments in this regard.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr T. O’Callaghan.

 

Cllr Flynn acknowledged the response but reiterated his belief that the car parking deficit has not been addressed.  He lamented hearing through local media that a loan had been approved for carparking at a Council meeting which he had been unable to attend.  He advised he was disappointed to see on the front pages that the Chief Executive had announced an agreement with the GAA for 200 car parking spaces, which Members had no detail on prior to the PR piece. Cllr Flynn highlighted a Director of Service report to Members in May 2017 promising 100 off-street spaces within 2 years and an additional 500 within 5 years, none of which were provided. He reiterated that under planning law, monies collected, if not used within 7 years, must be refunded.  His research, he stated, was based on figures provided.  The County Development Plan requires businesses to provide parking for their customers; this is not something the public should have to rely on and there was an obligation to provide for the public and for businesses alike.  He added that there was a further promise last year of 450 car parking spaces in the outskirts of town.  He expressed dissatisfaction with the response, highlighting that the issue with carparking is going on over 20 years.

 

 Cllr O’Callaghan supported this Motion and the need to have up-to-date information on the current status.  He welcomed item (d) in the response which seeks further provision of spaces in town centre.  He added that whilst the new bus routes and public realm works were to be welcomed, if the town is to grow to its full potential, the parking deficit needs to be addressed which he averaged at around 2000 spaces.  He highlighted the success of Kildare Village which is reaping the benefits of addressing parking need.  He cautioned also that surveys must take into account peak seasonal highs like Christmas and other holidays when parking is of the utmost importance to retailers who rely on these trading peaks.

 

 Cllr Colleran-Molloy stated that she did not now, nor during her Mayorship, experience evidence of a deficit of parking and could only envisage a deficit as meaning an inability to park directly outside a particular premises you wish to visit.   She cautioned the negative press being generated and its effect of putting people off visiting town.   She stated 20-year-old data is no longer relevant and it might have been prudent to include in the response a reference to the 199 spaces at the Cloister.  She also wished to ensure that any agreement with the GAA for car parking would be such that parking is available 24/7 and not just outside of GAA match fixtures.   She recommended getting a map of the carpark out to the public, with a note on what the Council achieved in the agreement with the GAA.

  

Sean Lenihan addressed the meeting, stating he had provided as much information as is available and that the report once published will be readily available to Members.  He quoted that Ennis has a comparatively strong ratio of spaces per population than other towns and cities (Ennis 1:13, Waterford city 1:29, Navan 1:34).  He assured Members that there is no money being borrowed to repay unutilised planning contributions, and that the loan for future planning in Ennis will be supplemented by monies already in the fund from contributions.  In relation to the proposed Cloister carpark, he advised that the Council have signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Clare GAA which will result in the delivery of 197 no. public parking spaces.  Furthermore, Members were reminded of the proposal to provide an additional 70 no. approx. carparking spaces at the Waterpark House Campus. 

He urged Members to remember that the whole carparking issue is a dynamic and constantly changing environment with many positive initiatives in the offing.   Members were reminded of the plans for a new Town Bus service which will reduce the dependency and requirement for a large number of car journeys along with other related plans for Active Travel schemes, Park & Ride/Stride, etc. all of which will bring enormous benefit and positively impact parking need and availability.

 

 

Item 8: Notice of Motion No. 4 Post Office Field, Clareabbey Wetlands and Roche Opportunity Site

Ar moladh Cllr. P. Murphy
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan agus glacadh leis

No. 4     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. P. Murphy                                             

“Vision for Ennis 2040, with reference to the following guiding principles as outlined in the executive summary document:

Principle 1. Develop a distinctive Ennis.

Principle 4. Promote a high quality of life, health and well-being.

Principle 5. Maximise and enhance the opportunities offered by the scenic landscapes of Clare.

Principle 8. Build a resilient and adaptable economy.

Principle 11. Establish Ennis as a climate adaptive leader.

Principle 12. Carry out an Appropriate Assessment, Strategic Environmental Assessment and Strategic Flood Risk Assessment.

 

Ennis Municipal District request that priority is given to developing "Ireland's First Climate Adaptive Town" by working with the natural environmental assets of Ennis. This can be achieved by prioritising development at the Post Office Field, Clareabbey Wetlands & Enterprise Area, and the Roche Opportunity Site.”

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

Members will be aware that the Councils recently adopted Climate Action Plan 2024-2029 supports Ennis’s ambition to become "Ireland's First Climate Adaptive Town" and includes several actions that will over the lifetime of the plan directly and indirectly contribute towards this ambition. These include actions that support the wetland project in Ennis (Action C2.8), increase resilience to flooding in Ennis (Actions BE3.6 & BE3.7) and advance sustainable transportation in Ennis through EV Charging Infrastructure, Active Travel and Public Transport (Actions T1.1, T1.3, T1.4, T1.5, T1.6 T1.8 & T1.13).

 

Regarding the Post Office Field proposal, the Motion is timely in that the Public Consultation relating to same is currently being planned with the precise details to be advertised later in the week.  A Briefing to inform the Ennis MD Members beforehand will be arranged. 

 

This item was proposed by Cllr T. O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Murphy acknowledged the response and outlined to Members that the ethos of this Motion was to bring Members together in recognising the value in aligning Climate Action and Ennis 2040 complimentary objectives which can deliver huge benefits to the district in “wellness living”.  The Post Office Field project, Clareabbey Wetlands, River Fergus walkway and the Roche cleared site represent opportunity for Ennis and there is potential for a cycling route all the way along the estuary to Killimer.  These objectives, and their delivery, represent positive development for Ennis which should unite rather than divide Members in the mutual quest for a sustainable future.

 

Cllr O’Callaghan seconded the Motion and agreed that the climate approach represents an opportunity to achieve in terms of health and wellbeing. 

Cllr Howard commended Cllr Murphy’s dedication and considering how Members were just a year ago presented with the vision of the younger generation, which broadly seeks less dependence on cars, it is timely for Ennis to seize the opportunity to lead on Ireland’s first climate adaptive town.

 

Cllr Colleran-Molloy commended Cllr Murphy’s insight in drawing from the Climate action document and seeing Members as custodians of the future.  She commended the ambitious plans for the Post Office Field which she termed “the lungs of Ennis” and that delivering on these objectives will spearhead Ennis as a leader in climate adaptation.

 

Cllr Flynn supported this Motion, stating that it was disappointing that the timelines had been pushed out so far in favour of an unwelcome focus on development of open spaces.  Cllr Howard countered that she was in possession of the document issued by then Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on his visit to Ennis and she stated that Cllr Flynn was Mayor in 2019 and was part of these discussions and very much involved in taking the plans forward.  She stated that the strategy document, and the sites identified, had not changed since its inception.  Cllr Flynn replied that the document was essentially a guidance document, not a statutory document and that as Mayor of Ennis of course he engaged fully in it.  He advised that he left the board of Ennis2040 DAC because the 12 principles of the document were not adhered to.  Cllr Daly supported the Motion and that he would warmly welcome progress on the objectives and that it would be a huge positive just to see a new lease of life for the Roche site.

 

Cllr Norton stated that when Ennis 2040 was first brought to Ennis Members a number of years ago, she did question some items included but that when the then Director of Planning, Liam Conneally met with Members to clarify on these issues, her concerns were allayed.   Whilst Ennis M.D. would always be proud of having the capital town in the district, the negative publicity over the past number of months has served to detract from that advantage, and its important now to harness all positive initiatives that will bring benefit. She added that a failure to incentivise new businesses because of persistent negative press, will represent a grave injustice to the people of Ennis and Clare.  Cllr O’Callaghan responded that he does not seek to generate negative press, rather that it would be remiss of him not to duly reflect the concerns of the public he represents.

 

Cllr Murphy concluded that the Motion had received the support of the seven Ennis Members which was his goal, and that Ennis 2040 needs to heed that this is something Members are unified and focussed on as a group.  Cllr Murphy requested that the Motion, as written, is taken forward to the Board of Ennis2040, and not just inserted into records.   Sean Lenihan confirmed that the Motion would be taken forward for the attention of Director of Service, Carmel Kirby and the Board of Ennis2040.

 

Item 9: Notice of Motion No. 5  St. Michael’s Villas Road Surfacing

Ar moladh Cllr. M. Howard
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan  agus glacadh leis

 

No. 5     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. M. Howard

“St Michael's Villas.

I request a full inspection of the road resurfacing works completed last year ... these very proud residents are very disappointed with the appearance of this work. They believe it to be insufficient and will not be a long-term solution.”

 

Paddy Tiernan, A/Senior Executive Engineer, responded as follows:

The Ralumac surface installed last summer is an approved method for sealing and protecting roads in low trafficked areas with speed limits of 50kmph or less. This method is used extensively across the country and has been previously used without significant issue in many areas across Clare including Ennis. The purpose of the surface is to seal the existing road and thereby extend its lifespan. This type of surfacing is a cheaper alternative than a traditional road overlay. Residential areas in Ennis are very unlikely to receive funding for any other type of surface. This is especially prevalent in St Michaels Villas where the existing roads were of a concrete structure. The only alternative in this scenario would be to break up and remove the concrete and then construct a new road surface.  This is not a financially viable option, and such a methodology would likely cause damage to nearby structures.

As outlined above the purpose of the product is to extend the lifespan of the road and to prevent further deterioration and eventual failure of the surface below. The product whilst not as aesthetically pleasing as a traditional overlay is functional and serves an important role in the road maintenance strategy of all local authorities.  In light of the concerns raised Ennis Municipal District will ensure the contractor returns to site in order to carry out a further inspection of the works.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Howard acknowledged the response and expressed disappointment on behalf of the residents, as was the case for the residents of Hermitage in her March Notice of Motion.  Residents find the road surface to be flimsy and unprofessional.  Cllr O’Callaghan seconded the Motion, having visited the estate the previous day.

 

Cllr Colleran-Molloy, whilst reflecting the sentiment of the Motion, cautioned on the numerous requests directed to the A/SEE Paddy Tiernan for all manner of road works, and budget limitations.

 

Cllr Murphy supported the Motion and empathised with the residents, but understood the difficulty outlined in the response.  He added that budgets are limited, and it is incumbent on Members to pass budgets and ensure roads are safe and that the best possible work is being undertaken in the circumstances.

 

Cllr Daly supported the Motion and welcomed the response that a further review will be requested which may alleviate some of the concerns of residents.

 

Cllr Howard, in conclusion thanked Members for their support.  Paddy Tiernan estimated that the cost to re-do this project would be in the hundreds of €1,000s as there would be a requirement to break up the surface, remove it, and build a new road. This would also compromise the walls of the estate and the new surface would not be at the correct level.  He had liaised with Engineers in Galway, Limerick and Shannon, none of whom appear to be experiencing the same level of negative opinions for this product but that the Contractor will be asked to review the work. It is also worth noting, he added, that the surface needs traffic in order to bed-in, and it appears to smooth more effectively where this is the case.

 

Item 10: Notice of Motion No. 6 Rates Revaluation Ennis  

Ar moladh Cllr. P. Daly
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan agus glacadh leis

 

No. 6     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. P. Daly                                                        

“I request the CEO of Clare County Council to advise how best to postpone the inordinate burden on Ennis rate payers arising from the recent increase on valuation of properties, pending the completion of the current works taking place in the town.”

 

Trina Rynne, Financial Accountant, Finance & Support Services, replied as follows:

In 2023 the National Revaluation programme, managed by Tailte Éireann, aimed at ensuring that the rateable valuation of all commercial and industrial property in Ireland reflects the current business environment, was completed for County Clare.

 

The outcome of this process resulted in no increase in Commercial Rates year on year for this council.   

 

In reviewing all properties within Ennis Municipal District, for 2024 commercial rates, the following is the actual outcome for the properties and the businesses as a result of this rebalancing:

 

• Six out of 10 rate payers are seeing a reduction.
• 2 of every 10 see an average increase of €220 per annum.
• A further 2 of every 10 see an increase above €500 per annum.

The exercise did result in increases for some properties, but it should be noted that All business owners were afforded the opportunity to query and or appeal the valuation during the process. Appeals for County Clare are 214 appeals out of 4135 – which is 5.17% of all commercial properties under Revaluation.

 

Where Commercial rate customers are indicating difficulty to members in meeting their commercial rates liability, they are encouraged to engage with their account manager to agree a payment arrangement.  It is noteworthy that in 2023, where there was no pandemic waiver of commercial rates for any period, over 88% of commercial rates were paid in the year. Several businesses in the Ennis Municipal District have indicated some of their best years trading despite the post pandemic environment.  Company Office Returns of trading data for several businesses substantiates this position.

 

In relation to the current Public Realm enhancements for O’Connell Street, Barrack Street, Bank Place, and the Height this represents a significant investment by Clare County Council to greatly improve the area and enhance its attractiveness and accessibility for all and encourage continued and future investment in the town. €8.7M will be funded via Urban Regeneration Development Fund (URDF) with Clare County Council contributing an additional €3m in match funding, to complete this €12m project.

Commercial Rates are the main funding source for the general provision of services by the Council and the match funding of this and many other schemes. It is important to note that this match funding investment on the two phases, URDF and a loan of €7.1m for the Ennis Library development, has in recent years been made from the annual budget process.

There is no mechanism in the absence of Ministerial approval for the waiving of all or part of the annual Rates in any part of County Clare for upgrade and or development works. The Local Government Rates and Other Matters Act 2019 was passed by the Oireachtas in 2019. The overarching purpose of the Act was to modernise the collection of commercial rates. The Act contains provisions in Section 15 relating to potential Alleviation Schemes, that have not been commenced as ministerial regulations are pending. These provisions will empower the Elected Members of Local Authorities to devise and achieve policy objectives through locally targeted rates waiver schemes into the future subject to their annual budget process.

While acknowledging the justifiable concerns of the businesses affected by these works there are schemes available in relation to commercial rates relief:

• Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) Scheme - Business with a commercial rates liability of up to €10,000 can avail of a 5% credit if they discharge their commercial rates per the terms of the scheme within the year.
• Hospitality Support Scheme- Business with a commercial rates liability greater €10,000 can avail of a 5% credit, per the terms of the scheme, if they discharge their commercial rates in the year.
• Long Term Vacant Property Incentive Scheme - Clare County Council operates the long-term vacant property scheme to encourage the use of vacant commercial premises in towns and villages in Clare.
• Increased Cost of Business (ICOB) Grant- The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment (DETE) has made a grant available to qualifying businesses as a contribution to the rising costs faced by businesses. This rollout will be managed by Clare County Council and the amount of the grant payable to eligible businesses is based on the value of the Commercial Rates bills issued to business in 2023.

Details of all the above schemes are available on https://www.clarecoco.ie/

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

Cllr Daly acknowledged the in-depth response, noting that it was the revaluation exercise which had led to the increase in rates levels and whilst public realm works are ongoing, businesses are losing income whilst still being burdened by rates.  He regretted the fact that many businesses did not avail of the appeals process, and he would wish to see the revaluation stalled just for the duration of the public realm works.  Whilst Cllr Daly could appreciate the response from the Financial Accountant, it would not be of any assistance to affected businesses.

Cllr O’Callaghan seconded the Motion stating that without Ministerial approval local representatives are left with no voice to influence a remedy for local businesses and that Members should raise the issue with Clare Oireachtas Members so it can be taken to the Minister.  He also recommended that the contractors be requested to carry out work later into the evening to help speed up the process.

Cllr Colleran Molloy supported this Motion and sympathised with traders affected and whilst the outcome of the works would benefit all, she shared the concern for businesses.  She also noted in the response that overall, the cost of rates has gone down in many cases, and there is rebate potential.  She commended this very good motion which was sensitive to traders, and she would support any alleviation of rates.

Cllr Howard reminded the Meeting of the reality that this is out of their gift.  However, it was the elected representatives’ responsibility to be visionary in showcasing how the streets will look when works are complete and, in the meantime, to promote the grants available, quite sizeable grants which for many would be most welcome. 

Cllr Daly made a request that the CE raise this at CCMA.  He thanked Members for their support.

Sean Lenihan confirmed that he will take up this matter with Clare Oireachtas Members with an aim to give some control back to local representatives.  Rebates would be open to all businesses, not limited to those affected by public realm works.  In relation to the public realm contract, the Council liaises on an ongoing basis and every opportunity to speed up the process is automatically pursued.

 

 

Item 11: Notice of Motion No. 7  Kilnamona – Local Link Bus Stop

Ar moladh Cllr. C. Colleran-Molloy
Cuidithe ag Cllr.M. Howard agus glacadh leis

No. 7     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. Clare Colleran-Molloy

“Kilnamona

That the EMD communicate with the Local Link Bus service to have a stop provided at Kilnamona Cross.”

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

Members will be aware that the existing 331 Bus Service operates to and from Ennis, through Inagh and onto the North Clare towns of Ennistymon and Ballyvaughan.  Currently, there isn’t any official Bus Stop provided for at Kilnamona but I am happy to raise this request with both Local Link and the National Transport Authority (NTA).

 

I will update the Members on developments in this regard once received.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr M Howard and agreed by all Members.

Cllr Colleran-Molloy commended the reinvigoration of the Local Link Bus Service and she received requests from residents whose teenage children wished to access the route in pursuit of seasonal work in Lahinch, and that a bus stop here would be invaluable to rural areas who are outside of the catchment bus service.

Cllr Howard supported this Motion and vouched for this excellent bus service, having received many calls from satisfied customers.  The addition of Kilnamona would not only be very positive for that locality, it would serve to enhance the viability of the service in the longer term.

 

Cllr Murphy, in support, having liaised with Cillian Griffey, Manager of Local Link had reported that there is a safety issue at Kilnamona Cross and that it would be great if the Council worked with them on this.  Cllrs O’Callaghan and Daly also supported this Motion, Cllr Daly stating that it would be a crucial to include a Kilnamona Stop on this route.  Cllr Colleran-Molloy thanked all Members for the support.

 

Item 12: Notice of Motion No. 8 Hawthorn Estate Speed Calming Measures

Ar moladh Cllr. T. O’Callaghan
Cuidithe ag Cllr. J. Flynn agus glacadh leis

No. 8     Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan

“With significant traffic activities increased within Hawthorn Estate due to additional homes can new speed calming ramps and signage be reviewed and installed in the interest of health and safety.”

 

Paddy Tiernan, A/Senior Executive Engineer, responded as follows:

Ennis MD recently carried out vehicular speed surveys over a 7-day period on the link roads between the Hawthorns and the two recently constructed new estates, namely Sycamore Drive and An Cósan Gheal. The survey recorded a total of 4,005 vehicular movements, 2,632 of whom were to and from An Cósan Gheal with the remaining 1,373 travelling to and from Sycamore Drive. The average speed of vehicles encountered was approximately 30kmph. The survey shows that less than 1% of vehicles exceeded the 50kmph speed limit which exists within the estate.

Notwithstanding that the vast majority of vehicles are in compliance with current limits Ennis MD would consider additional traffic calming measures to be appropriate given the nature of estate and the volume of vehicles encountered. Ennis MD will analyse the various traffic calming options available and will prepare a Section 38 for this scheme. We note that no funding is currently available for the implementation of such measures. However, such a scheme may be suitable for an application to the NTA under the next round of Low-Cost Safety Scheme funding.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr J. Flynn and agreed by all Members.

Cllr O’Callaghan thanked Paddy Tiernan for the detailed response and the positive speed limit compliance stats captured in the survey.  However, the potential for an accident remains a worry.  Paddy Tiernan clarified that IPB, the Council insurers, advised against temporary ramps so this option, whilst being effective, is not available. He quoted a cost of circa €7.5k for a permanent ramp. 

Cllr Flynn supported this Motion.  Cllr Daly supported the Motion reminding Members that a further estate Bramble Lane is located at the back of this estate, so traffic volume is a concern. Cllr Howard supported the Motion and informed the meeting that she has a Notice of Motion to Clare County Council seeking the standardisation to 30kph of all speed limits in these zones.  Cllr Murphy supported this Motion, and similar to Notice of Motion No. 1, ‘Children at Play’ signage would be appropriate at this location also.

 

Cllr O’Callaghan concluded thanking Members for their support.

 

Item 13: Notice of Motion No. 9  Ballyallia Lake Footpaths & Changing Rooms

Ar moladh Cllr. J. Flynn
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan  agus glacadh leis

 

No. 9 Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. J. Flynn                                                             

“Investment in Ballyallia Lake recreational areas. 

I request a report on how much GMA funding has been allocated and unspent on investment in Ballyallia Lake recreational areas.  (I understand up to €125,000 might be available) and

I propose that it be urgently be used prior to Summer 2024 to provide. 

 

1) resurfacing of footpaths on Health & Safety grounds 

2) provision of a changing unit for the swimmers. 

 

In my role as chair of the Ballyallia Blue Flag working group I acknowledge investment and improvements has occurred in the last decade we had requested, including public toilets, lifeguards, public lighting and seating, maintenance of shrubs/trees, 5k loop walk, etc.” 

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

Members will be aware of the exciting plans that we have for Ballyallia.  It is hoped following some final seasonal environmental surveys to be completed, that we will then be in a position to submit for the necessary statutory consents.  In the interim, we will endeavour to ensure the facilities and amenity there is fit for purpose.  At present, Ennis MD staff maintain the bins and surrounding area and the mobile Toilet Block is being maintained under contract by a third party. 

 

In terms of monies allocated and remaining unspent from recent GMA, I wish to advise as follows:

 

Historical Amount transferred from Ennis Town Council	€25,765.00
Amount allocated in 2017 to Ballyallia Improvement scheme:	€25,000.00
Amount allocated in 2018 to Ballyallia Improvement Scheme:	€25,000.00
Total Monies allocated	€75,765.00
Expenditure recorded on the job code currently.	-€10,799.81
Remaining Monies	€64,965.19

 

In addition to the above, over €130k expenditure was incurred last year under the Community Recognition Fund in the provision of new public lighting from the Gort Road junction to Ballyallia Lake.  Moreover, we were successful in securing €50k under the Project Development Measure ORIS funding for Ballyallia.  Work continues on the development of the overall Enhancement Project which will include changing facilities for Swimmers. In the meantime, as requested in the Motion, we will consider what temporary facilities may be possible and an inspection of the footpaths there, as referenced, will be carried out at the earliest juncture and any urgent repairs will be completed.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. T. O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Flynn acknowledged the response and recommended the €65,000 be used to finish work on footpaths and to provide shelter for bathers.

Cllr O’Callaghan seconded this Motion and the importance of maintaining this amenity.  Cllr Murphy supported the Motion commenting on the prevalence of year-round swimming such that the lifeguard facility was reinstated during lockdown years.  Cllr Howard supported the Motion recommending the footpaths are widened so people can walk 2-abreast, highlighted some ponding areas. Cllr Daly supported the Motion and that Ballyallia will benefit from a facelift, especially the car parking areas and the possibility of removing the large stones adjacent.

Cllr Colleran-Molloy in support requested timeframes for more substantial enhancement scheme.   Cllr Norton referenced the extensive consultation over the years and that having done so much groundwork, pressure should be put on government for the completion of the enhancement scheme.

Sean Lenihan welcomed the unified approach of Members on this matter and that currently there are environmental and ecological challenges being faced in the planning process, some surveys, such as Wintering Birds surveys are limited to particular times of year.  Once complete, the application for this type of scheme will go directly to An Bord Pleanála.  In the meantime, interim measures would be very welcome to keep the amenity in good stead and he referenced the Community Recognition Fund recently announced for 2024, as well as a further call for URDF funding which is imminent.

 

Cllr Flynn concluded by thanking Members for their support and reiterating it would be great if footpath situation could be addressed, particularly following the successful public lighting and loop walk works funded last year.

 

Item 14: Notice of Motion No. 10 Ballybeg Footpaths & Lighting

Ar moladh Cllr. P. Murphy
Cuidithe ag Cllr. C. Colleran-Molloy  agus glacadh leis

No. 10 Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. P. Murphy

“I am requesting that the Ballybeg footpath & lighting scheme is completed in its entirety, thereby fully linking Ballybeg to the Ennis to Kildysart Road by footpath. This can be achieved by making Ballybeg Bridge a single lane road, constructing a footpath on one side of the Bridge and giving priority to incoming traffic thereby preventing traffic from backing up onto the Kildysart Road. An appropriate street lighting scheme would also need to be incorporated as this area is currently very dangerous during the hours of darkness.”

 

Paddy Tiernan, A/Senior Executive Engineer, responded as follows:

The continuation and completion of footpaths on the L-4176 in Ballybeg footpaths is a priority for Ennis MD. Approximately 150m of footpath remains outstanding at the Kildysart Road end of Ballybeg. Earlier this year Ennis MD together with our colleagues in the Active Travel Team put this project forward to the NTA for funding under the Active Travel Scheme for 2024. Unfortunately, this application was not successful. We are currently exploring alternative sources of funding for this project and hope to have an update in the coming weeks. Currently Ennis MD staff are in the process of preparing detailed drawings for this scheme and will also re-commence engagement with affected landowners with a view to lodging a Section 38 application within the coming months.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. C. Colleran Molloy and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Murphy welcomed the response but expressed disappointment that the Active Travel funding did not materialise for this fantastic wall.  Cllr Colleran Molloy welcomed this Motion and said she would support the use of GMA for the circa €70k cost of this project if other funding does not materialise.  She praised the works undertaken in past few years and will support any measure to slow traffic down in the area.  Cllrs O’Callaghan, Daly and Howard supported this Motion, commenting on the increased popularity of the walking route and obvious benefits of its completion, Cllr Howard agreeing that GMA would be appropriate to this type of project.  Cllr Murphy thanked Members for their support.

Sean Lenihan added that there is no impediment to Members getting together and agreeing to fund this or other projects through their GMA fund.

 

Item 15: Notice of Motion No. 11 Wooden Fencing Cahercalla Estate and Drumcliffe Road

Ar moladh Cllr. M. Howard
Cuidithe ag Cllr. T. O’Callaghan agus glacadh leis

No. 11 Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. M. Howard

“Wooden Fencing.

Fencing around the town needs to be inspected and replaced. I am referring specifically to wooden fencing at the entrance to Cahercalla Estate on the Kilrush Rd and on the Drumcliffe Road junction before the Lee's Rd Complex.”

 

Paddy Tiernan, A/Senior Executive Engineer, responded as follows:

Ennis MD will carry out a full inspection of the wooden fencing within the coming weeks with a view to repairing/replacing as required. The entrance to Cahercalla Estate on the Kilrush Rd and on the Drumcliffe Road junction before the Lee's Rd Complex will be prioritised.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. T O’Callaghan and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Howard acknowledged the response and understood that the preferable remedy may be the replacement of the damaged and unsightly fence with a more economical alternative.  Cllr O’Callaghan seconded this Motion.  Cllrs Daly and Flynn also supported and Cllr Colleran Molloy in support, also commended the improvements at Ballybeg cul de sac car park.

 

Item 16: Notice of Motion No. 12  Billboard O’Connell Street – Ennis is Open for Business

Ar moladh Cllr. P. Daly
Cuidithe ag Cllr. M. Howard agus glacadh leis

No. 12 Notice of Motion submitted by Cllr. P Daly                                                         

“I request Ennis MD to look at the possibility of leasing out the large billboard on the left-hand side of Daniel O’Connell monument until works are complete at O’Connell Street by advertising all the businesses on the street so that it will let people know that its business as usual in their street.”

 

Sean Lenihan, Senior Engineer, responded as follows:

The Motion is timely in that Ennis MD staff are at present considering various options for promoting and supporting business and optimising the commercial offering during the ongoing Public Realm works.  These include our recent media campaign in print and radio as well as the supports offered by our colleagues in Finance and Local Enterprise Office. 

 

In fact, the use of the advertising billboard on the gable close to the Daniel O’Connell monument on O’Connell Square is one of the options being considered alongside others including street specific messaging and graphics.  It is in private ownership, but preliminary discussions have already taken place with the owner of the billboard and a decision will be made in coming weeks as to the viability or otherwise of this option.  The ultimate decision will depend on a number of factors including effectiveness, value for money, and level of universal benefit achieved for business activity in the town centre.  Given the number of businesses operating in the Town, if the Billboard was to be used, the information on it would need to be of a more general nature emphasising the towns welcome, vibrancy, and range of services. 

 

I will keep the Members informed of developments in this regard.

 

This item was seconded by Cllr. M. Howard and agreed by all Members.

 

Cllr Daly welcomed the response and said that an information billboard would serve to emphasise that Ennis is open for business and would also demonstrate to businesses that the inconvenience they are experiencing is understood and supported by Ennis M.D. Cllr Howard seconded the Motion and would be keen to see any visuals to showcase the “finished product” as a way of alleviating the difficulty faced by businesses currently and she recommended advertising on existing hoarding to be bigger and more pronounced.

 

Cllrs Flynn, O’Callaghan and Colleran-Molloy supported this Motion, with reference made to a high quality offering akin to “Times Square”, or the potential to hang a mesh drape with an image on it, any possible PR measures to show that supporting businesses is a priority for the Municipal District.

Sean Lenihan addressed the meeting, wishing to assure Members that everything is being done to alleviate the impact the works may have on business.  There were safety issues in regard to an earlier proposal to install large, perforated screens with graphics of what the completed works would look like.  Alternative options are being considered such as overhead street banners or large montages on display boards fixed to suitable wall locations.   Cllr Daly concluded he would welcome any assistance to businesses.

 

Item 17: Correspondence

Ennis Mayor Cllr Pat Daly received correspondence from St. Michael’s Villas. Niamh O’Connor Meetings Administrator read out the letter which expressed appreciation to the Mayor for the occasion of their Choir being honoured at the recent Mayoral Reception.

Item 18: Any Other Business

• Cllr O’Callaghan referenced July Minutes 2023 Matters Arising whereby a report was to be provided to members upon the winding down of Experience Ennis, which has not yet been provided.
• Cllr Howard wished to honour the following sporting organisations for their success in recent weeks:
  • Ladies Hockey team, who won the Munster Cup (despite having no home ground).
  • Ennis/Kilrush Senior Ladies Rugby Team were crowned the Div 1 Munster League Champions.
  • Ennis u/18s Girls Rugby Team, who won the Plate Title in Coonagh this past weekend
  • Good Luck to the Clare Ladies Gaelic Football Team in the League Final (Div 3) this weekend. 
• Cllr Howard commended the following groups for awards received in recent weeks:
  • Irish (Munster) Restaurant Awards:
  • Dermot Fetton - Earl of Thomond Restaurant in Dromoland Castle - Best Restaurant Manager.
  • Dromoland Castle - Best Hotel / Guesthouse Restaurant.
  • The Peppermill - Best Sustainable Practices category winner
  • Tulsi Restaurant - Best World Cuisine category winner
  • Henry's Bistro - Best Wine Experience category.
  •  
• Cllr Howard also commended Ennis M.D. for the successful organisation of St. Patrick’s Day parade and she congratulated Mayor Pat Daly who had represented Ennis so well and it was wonderful to have singer Maura O’Connell as special guest this year.
• Sean Lenihan updated on the interim measures for Shanaway Road junction – feedback on the feasibility report has just gone back to TII.
• Cllr P Murphy congratulated the Clare Ladies Football team on their promotion to Division 2 for 2025 and wished them Good Luck in the League Final.
• Cllr P Murphy wished to issue Good Luck to the Clare Senior Hurling Team in the Hurling League Final this weekend and to the Clare U20 Hurling Team starting out on Friday evening in the first of the round robin matches.
• Members joined Mayor P. Daly in extending sympathy to the family of the late Timmy Murphy R.I.P. who had played for Ennis Albion before moving to Galway.

Conclusion

The meeting ended at 13:10pm.

Signed: ____________________________
Riarthóir Cruinnithe

Signed: _____________________________
Cathaoirleach

Date:                  _____________________________

Page last reviewed: 07/05/24

Content managed by: Ennis Municipal District

Back to top